Florida's Controversial Bill SB 1580 Grants Medical Professionals The Right To Refuse Treatment Based On Conscience

Sep 19, 2023 at 01:15 pm by Matt

Bill SB 1580


Florida’s controversial new bill SB 1580 gives medical professionals the right to refuse treatment based on conscience. The Florida Senate has recently passed a bill that has ignited a firestorm of controversy, with implications for both medical professionals and insurance companies. SB 1580 allows medical providers to decline healthcare services on the basis of their moral objections, and it also enables insurance companies to deny coverage for procedures that contravene their stated moral or religious principles.

Under the proposed law, entities such as hospitals and insurance companies must possess official documents, including mission statements and governing records, outlining their ethical, moral, or religious guidelines to assert a "conscience" objection.

What Is Bill SB 1580?

Referred to as SB 1580, this bill empowers medical healthcare providers in the state of Florida to refuse healthcare services without being subject to civil liability if they do so based on conscientious objections. In a similar vein, insurance companies can opt not to cover specific medical services if they run counter to their established conscience-based guidelines. However, it's worth emphasizing that individuals still retain the right to take legal action for other transgressions, including instances of medical malpractice.

Critics of the legislation are deeply concerned that it might embolden medical professionals to discriminate against individuals, particularly those in the LGBTQ+ community. Despite efforts by Democratic lawmakers to expand the bill's provisions to include safeguards against discrimination based on disability, gender identity, sexuality, and marital status, these amendments were not included. The bill explicitly prohibits service refusal based on "race, color, religion, sex, or national origin."

SB 1580 Passed The House

Senator Tracie Davis, a Democrat hailing from Jacksonville, has vehemently voiced her opposition to the bill, characterizing it as inherently discriminatory. In contrast, proponents of the legislation argue that it is essential to safeguard the religious freedoms of doctors. House sponsor Rep. Joel Rudman, a Republican representing Navarre, has emphasized that the bill does not legitimize discrimination in any way.

The Senate passed the bill with a 28-11 vote, and it is now anticipated to undergo a House vote later in the week. This legislative session marks the final week of Florida's legislative calendar.

It is important to note that a similar bill was proposed last year but failed to progress through committee meetings. The current legislation defines a "conscience" objection as one rooted in a "sincerely held religious, moral, or ethical belief."

Laws Already Provide Conscience Protection

While existing state and federal laws already provide conscience protections for Florida medical providers concerning abortions and contraception, the new bill broadens these protections. It allows doctors to refuse any medical procedure if it goes against their conscience. Notably, the bill does not specify which medical procedures can be declined.

Rep. Joel Rudman, who is also a medical doctor, has underscored that the bill is his primary motivation for serving in the Florida Legislature. He disclosed that he faced an investigation by the American Board of Medicine after publicly expressing objections to COVID restrictions and the guidance of Anthony Fauci during Fauci's tenure as the White House's chief medical adviser.

The bill also contains provisions stating that professional boards cannot take disciplinary action against individuals solely based on their social media posts, as long as the content adheres to other legal requirements. Furthermore, the legislation guarantees that neither medical professionals nor insurance companies can be subjected to discrimination for refusing to participate in or fund specific healthcare services. Individuals or groups who believe they have experienced discrimination due to a "conscience" objection can file a complaint with the attorney general.

Does Not Supersede The Federal Emergency Medical Treatment

The bill explicitly clarifies that it does not supersede the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, which obligates hospitals to stabilize any patient with an emergency condition.

For entities like insurance companies and hospitals to assert a "conscience" objection, they must maintain official records, mission statements, or governing documents delineating their ethical, moral, or religious principles. Medical professionals who choose to decline treatment under this law must document their decision in the patient's medical records and provide written notice to their employer.

About Orlando Medical News

Orlando Medical News is the number one news source for medical-related content in Central Florida. Through twenty years of service, we’ve cultivated a strong audience of dedicated healthcare professionals. Orlando Medical News is your source for the best medical news in Central Florida and your trusted advertising platform which reaches far into the medical community of Central Florida healthcare professionals.
Sections: Digital Editions